Zappos VIP Points Store leads to a Very Nice 404 Page

While I was browsing on Zappos, I noticed that they have a Points Store for their VIP users (which I happen to be): 

Image

After clicking through, I was served with an array of redemption options: 

Image

Here, the interesting thing is, any redemption option that I click on, leads to a 404 page: 

Image

 

While this is most likely a bug, and not the desirable user experience, the 404 page that I’ve been served is very creative and should be applauded. There are three options: Try A SearchGo Home, and Get Help. The most amazing thing about this graphic is that for each button that you hover your mouse over, you get a corresponding image that points you to where exactly that button takes you. Almost like a meta-site-awareness. Take a look below at the three screenshots for the three mouse hover states: 

Image

 

Image

 

Image

 

 

 

Advertisement

Zappos Price Search Filter Doesn’t Make Sense

When searching for shoes on Zappos, you can filter search results by price. As seen below, the four options are:

A: $50 and Under
B: $100 and Under
C: $200 and Under
D: $200 and Over

Image

This is really strange for the following reasons:
1. The four groups are not mutually exclusive. Groups A and D are independent groups. Group B includes all of the shoes in Group A in addition to the shoes that are between $50 and $100. Group C includes all of the shoes in Group B (which includes Group A shoes!!) in addition to the shoes that are between $100 and $200.
2. What if the user wanted to search for shoes that were between $50 and $100 OR between $100 and $200. As its currently implemented, the user cannot.
3. It is an inconsistent pattern. You start with Group A that stands alone. Then Group B includes Group A. OK, fine. Then Group C includes Group B (which includes Group A). OK, fine. Then all of a sudden, Group D comes along and is independent from the bunch??
4. The UI control allows the user to select more than one option! As seen above, Groups B and C are selected. This is no different than just selecting Group C. So what was the point??

Here is the better design:

Arrange the different price groups into the following options:

A: $50 and Under
B: $50 – $100
C: $100 – $200
D: $200 and Over

For the UI control, allow the user to select more than one option.